Why does this annoy me?

This was the title of an article in the UK’s Independent newsaper: “Mature talent is celebrated with 'Silver Booker' list”

The article went to say, “They are the silver-haired doyens of British society who, cliché dictates, should be preparing themselves for the more tranquil world of bus passes and pensions. Instead, they are vying for recognition at the literary award known as the ‘Silver Booker’. Yesterday, seven British writers above the age of 50 were unveiled in the final shortlist of the Saga Award for Wit. The magazine-sponsored awards target older writers at the peak of their careers.”

So why my annoyance? I just don’t like being pigeon-holed into a group that is seen as so different that it requires its own award. I feel exactly the same about awards for people who are women, black, disabled or any other variety. There is an unspoken assumption that the people in these groups wouldn’t succeed in winning an award, open to all comers.

Saga’s interest in the award is all to do with its promotional value, which is a totally understandable motive. It still annoys me though. Dick Stroud: www.20plus30.com